Review by Jon Donnis
The Yoda Puppetronic by RealFX is one of those products that immediately catches your attention. At 44cm tall, this officially licensed 2026 Star Wars collectible has an impressive presence, and placed on a shelf or sideboard, it looks far more like a premium character display piece than a conventional toy.
The first thing that stands out is how good Yoda looks. The outfit is well made, and the overall design captures the familiar character extremely well. In fact, as a display piece, this is one of the best Yoda figures I have come across. It has plenty of presence, looks great from across the room and is almost guaranteed to attract comments when people see it for the first time.
The voice is another particularly strong aspect. With more than 120 sounds, there is plenty of dialogue and character interaction to discover, and the voice effects are remarkably convincing. I have no idea whether the recordings are from the original actor or an extremely good impersonator, but either way, the result is excellent. My only criticism is that the voice is quite quiet, and there is no volume control to increase it.
One feature I particularly enjoy is simply leaving Yoda switched on while he sits on the side. Every so often, he will deliver one of his familiar lines, which can be surprisingly funny when you are not expecting it. It gives him a little extra character and makes him feel less like a conventional static display figure.
I was also curious to see how a baby would react to Yoda. Obviously, this is not a toy intended for babies, but I wondered whether the unusual appearance and movements might be intimidating. There was some initial hesitation, but that quickly turned into waving at Yoda and attempts to communicate with him through enthusiastic babbling. It was rather cute, particularly because there was no familiarity with Star Wars or the character behind the reaction.
Unfortunately, the biggest weakness of the Yoda Puppetronic is directly related to what makes it different from a conventional figure. It is a puppetronic rather than an animatronic.
That is an important distinction.
There are no independently controlled movements. Yoda will not suddenly move his head, blink or perform actions by himself. The voice is effectively the only automated feature, with Yoda able to randomly play one of his lines when left switched on. Anyone expecting an animatronic character that can seemingly come alive on its own should be aware of this before buying.
The movements are controlled manually, and this is where things become considerably less impressive.
On paper, operating a Yoda puppet sounds like a lot of fun. Unfortunately, the controls are stiff and require quite a bit of effort. Getting the movements to look natural takes practice, and when somebody else is watching you operate him, it can be quite obvious that you are physically manipulating a puppet rather than bringing Yoda convincingly to life.
The main controls are located inside a compartment on Yoda's back. There is a fairly sizeable joystick used to control the movements, although the layout feels oddly suited to a left-handed user. For a mass market product, that seems like an unusual design decision.
The mechanism for raising Yoda's arm into his familiar Force pose is particularly stiff. A switch inside the rear control compartment operates the arm, and it requires a surprisingly firm movement to activate. The result is functional, but the action does not feel especially smooth or natural.
That stiffness is the biggest issue I have with the Puppetronic. A puppet should encourage you to pick it up, experiment with it and perform with it. With Yoda, there is enough resistance in the controls that it becomes more of a chore to make him look convincing. I can see the appeal of learning the movements, particularly for a dedicated Star Wars fan, but I am not sure many people will find themselves using it regularly.
There are a few other design annoyances worth mentioning.
During unboxing, Yoda's feet and cane need to be fitted. Thankfully, this is something you only have to do once, but attaching the feet is surprisingly difficult. They require quite a bit of force to push into position, so it can initially feel as though you are doing something wrong.
The battery compartment is another frustration. It is located on the back in a position that makes accessing it extremely awkward. Replacing batteries should be a simple task, but getting to the compartment is unnecessarily difficult.
Then there is Yoda's hair, or rather, the lack of it.
The real Yoda has his distinctive wispy white hair, yet the Puppetronic has none. It may seem like a small omission, but once you notice it, it is difficult to ignore. The costume and overall appearance are so good that the absence of the hair feels particularly strange, and it leaves the finished character looking slightly less complete than it could have been.
Scale is another point worth considering. The Puppetronic measures 44cm, compared with the real Yoda's 66cm height. That puts it at approximately 2:3 scale. Considering the size of the finished product, I do wonder why RealFX did not go all the way and produce a full-scale Yoda. It would obviously have required more space, but the difference in size would not have been enormous compared with what we already have here.
Despite all these criticisms, I still really like the Yoda Puppetronic.
The reason is simple. As a display piece, it is excellent.
Put Yoda on a shelf or sideboard and he looks fantastic. The quality of the costume, the likeness and the convincing voice combine to make something that feels much more substantial than an ordinary toy. The occasional voice activation is also a nice touch, particularly when Yoda unexpectedly delivers a familiar phrase while you are doing something else.
It is when you start treating it as a puppet that the problems become much more obvious.
If your intention is to control Yoda, entertain friends, take him to conventions or use him in videos, you will need patience. The joystick is stiff, the arm control is stiff and making the movements appear natural takes considerable effort. It is certainly possible to get more out of him with practice, but the basic experience is not as enjoyable as I would have expected from a product designed around puppetry.
That makes the £79.99 RRP a difficult proposition.
If you want a fantastic-looking Yoda to display, the Puppetronic makes a surprisingly strong case for itself. You are effectively getting a very impressive character display piece with a voice feature and manually controlled movements thrown in.
If you are buying it primarily because you want to operate a Yoda puppet, however, the decision becomes much harder. You need to really love the character, have the patience to work with the controls and be willing to put in the effort required to make the movements convincing. The design may also feel more natural for left-handed users.
For me, there is a very clear difference between the two experiences. I really like the Yoda Puppetronic as a figure. I am far less enthusiastic about it as a puppet.
As a display figure: 9/10
As a puppet: 5/10
Overall, the Yoda Puppetronic by RealFX is a great-looking piece that I am very happy to have sitting on the side. It looks the part, sounds the part and is a surprisingly entertaining conversation starter. I just wish the actual puppetry was as enjoyable as having Yoda sitting there looking fantastic.
You can Pre-Order from Amazon at https://link.amazon/B02nW5mMB
Thank you to WOW! STUFF for providing the Yoda Puppetronic for review.
No comments:
Post a Comment